Commerce Built for a 3,000-Store Co-op
Snapshot
Client | Do it Best is a U.S.-based, member-owned cooperative supplying hardware and building materials to 2,000+ members across 3,000 retail locations in 50+ countries, with $5B in wholesale revenue and an estimated $14B in member retail sales.
Company | Publicis Sapient
Focus | B2B & B2C platform E-commerce Transformation
Role | Experience Lead, Design, Research
Team | 20 people across design, product, and engineering
Timeline | 10 months to launch
Impact | +67% online revenue, +60% increase in orders
Do it Best faced the challenge of optimizing its e-commerce B2B and B2C platform to remain competitive amid rapid Buy Online, Pick up In-Store (BOPIS) and digital growth.
Context
Do it Best needed to modernize its e-commerce platform to support online ordering and in-store pickup, with a consistent experience across doitbest.com and thousands of independently owned member stores.
The old site only showed local inventory, so customers missed products available elsewhere, and the experience varied from store to store.
Approach
The response centered on one connected platform: a single-vendor system linking 3,000+ stores instead of each running its own disconnected setup, built to move fast on fulfillment and flexible enough to scale, centralized enough to keep every store consistent, but adaptable enough to support individual store and web experiences as the network grew.
Each of the 3,000 member stores is independently owned and operated, yet customers expect a seamless retail experience across every touchpoint.
Strategy
The platform had to serve two audiences at once, corporate and local store owners, each with different needs. I interviewed store owners and stakeholders to find where the current experience broke down for each side, then tested directions with both groups. Here’s what came out of it:
Fulfillment that flexes. Same-day pickup, ship-to-store, delivery, and transfer, so customers could get products however worked for them.
Discovery that works. Helped users find products and verify real inventory fast, without store-hopping.
Tools built for the people using them. Designed Pick & Pack to streamline store-level fulfillment and make it reliable.
Member stores are mostly mom-and-pop shops serving rural areas, where shoppers built real relationships in person. But if an item wasn't in stock locally, they waited or drove to another store.
Challenge
Thousands of independent stores each had their own local customers and inventory quirks (livestock, lumber, and more), so one consistent platform had to flex without becoming inconsistent. Too rigid, and stores couldn’t reflect what made them work for their communities. Too flexible, and the “one platform” promise would fall apart store by store.
The co-op model sharpened that tension. Store owners were both customers of the corporate platform and operators serving their own shoppers, so getting the balance wrong hurt the people running the stores as well as the shoppers.
I addressed this with a modular template and header system paired with tiered customization, giving stores real flexibility within a consistent structure. It also let customers shop across stores within a single order, something the old fragmented setup never allowed.
Ownership
As Experience Lead, I directed a North American team of three designers alongside an India-based design pod, staying close to research and delivery.
Built the system across two continents. Built and scaled a reusable design system that kept design and UX standards consistent across both teams.
Aligned design and engineering. Ran development refinement sessions so both teams stayed aligned as work moved forward.
Owned the client relationship. Served as the main point of contact, presenting solutions and handling stakeholder feedback directly.
Checkout was losing customers and there was little budget to test. Recordings of real shoppers showed why they were leaving.
Impact
During the soft launch, Hotjar tracking showed high drop-off at Add to Cart and Checkout. Recordings showed that split co-op shipments confused shoppers about which store they were buying from, so we redesigned checkout to make the purchasing store and fulfillment method explicit.
Within the first two months of relaunch:
Revenue. Online revenue up 67%.
Orders. Orders up 60%, including 56% in ship-to-store.
Order value. Average order value up 4.6% after the checkout redesign.
Reflection
Global collaboration needs intentional alignment. The India team missed client review sessions because of time zones, so they heard decisions secondhand and context got lost. We started sending recordings and added more design syncs.
Small behaviors build stronger teams. Cameras stayed off on most remote calls, so people worked together for months without seeing each other. That made a real difference in how connected and collaborative the teams felt.
Testing needs buy-in early. Testing was treated as an afterthought when leadership first pitched the project, so mistakes traveled further than they should have. The value of testing needs buy-in from the whole team, not just the experience side.
Discovery Process
Facilitated a 2-day in-person discovery workshop with cross-functional client stakeholders to align on goals, surface priorities, and define project success criteria.
Shoppers access Do it Best through the main site or member sites. Two personas and journeys were mapped to capture these distinct paths.
Evaluated the site through heuristic principles to identify pain points and opportunities for improvement.
Performed a competitive analysis to identify strengths, gaps, and differentiators guiding strategy.
Built and scaled an accessible, reusable design system across U.S. and India teams, reducing inconsistencies and accelerating feature delivery.
Toolkit extension with component variations and pattern guides.
The Design System handoff included detailed component usage guidelines and requirements for designers, developers, and content authors. This was particularly valuable given the large CMS component, enabling authors (DIB & Members) to customize content effectively.
Designs
Produced mid-fidelity wireframes to test and refine the design system.
As a co-op, the challenge was to create a unified customer experience across DoitBest.com and member sites while supporting individual branding. To address this, we needed a header design that enabled customizable navigation and content.
Flexible header solution that accommodates both DoitBest.com and member sites.
Navigation
PLP
Mobile
PDP
Dealer Search and Results
As E-commerce orders grew, member stores lacked a fast, reliable way to fulfill same-day pickup and ship-to-store orders, resulting in operational delays and friction. The Pick & Pack App streamlined store fulfillment, enabling faster, more reliable same-day pickup and ship-to-store orders.